← Back to the journal

All that glitters is not silver: what the BBC found in "sterling" jewellery

6 Nov 2026 · Anna · fake sterling silver · hallmarks · how to tell if silver is real
All that glitters is not silver: what the BBC found in "sterling" jewellery

I'd love to tell you I was surprised by this one. But I hear what you tell me at the stall about the ring from a marketplace that turned your finger green, or the earrings that turned your ears into a scab fest. So when the BBC published the results of a Watchdog investigation into "sterling silver" sold online, I read it with a cuppa and a lot of nodding.

What the BBC found

Watchdog, the consumer show that now runs on The One Show, bought 25 pieces of jewellery advertised as 925 or sterling silver from Amazon, eBay, Temu, Etsy and OnBuy. Some were very cheap: a bracelet for £1.55 and earrings for £1.99. They sent them all to the Sheffield Assay Office for testing.

  • Only two of the 25 could be classified as sterling silver.
  • Eight contained cadmium over the legal limit of 0.01%. Some had up to 10%. Cadmium is a carcinogen, and the risk comes from swallowing or breathing it in, for example an earring that falls into your food. Three of the eight came from Amazon, three from Temu, and one each from OnBuy and Etsy.
  • One woman, Meranda, bought a £15 necklace on Etsy listed as handmade sterling silver. It was stamped 925 and looked, in her words, "very shiny… legit". Within a few days her neck was irritated. Testing found nickel, as high as 11% in one part of the chain, and only 8.9% silver in another. Real sterling has to be at least 92.5%.

Selling fake sterling silver breaks the Hallmarking Act. The marketplaces told the BBC that misleading listings are not allowed and that they had removed the pieces Watchdog found; Amazon and OnBuy have issued recalls. Etsy did not respond. You can read the whole BBC article here.

A 925 stamp on its own proves nothing

This is the bit I want everyone to take away. Meranda's necklace had 925 stamped on it. Anyone can stamp a number on a piece of metal, and when the seller is on the other side of the world there is very little to stop them.

A UK hallmark is different. It is applied by an independent Assay Office after they have tested the metal, and it is a legal guarantee. A full hallmark has a sponsor's mark (the maker's initials in a shield), the fineness mark (925 for sterling) and the Assay Office's own mark. For Sheffield, that is a rose. In the UK, anything sold as silver that weighs over 7.78 g has to be hallmarked. Pieces under that weight, like most studs, can be sold as silver without one. I have written more about this in UK silver hallmarks explained and what 925 actually means.

How to avoid the sh*te

  • If the price is unbelievable, believe that. Silver is a precious metal and it costs real money by the gram, before anyone has made anything from it. A £1.55 "sterling" bracelet is not sterling.
  • Look for a full hallmark on heavier pieces. A bangle, a chunky ring or a big pendant sold as silver in the UK should carry one. Just "925" on a heavy piece is a question worth asking.
  • Ask the seller. Where does your silver come from? Who hallmarks your work? A real maker will be happy to tell you, and probably at length.
  • Listen to your skin. Itching, scabby ears or a rash within days can point to nickel, which sterling silver does not normally contain. (A faint grey-green mark on your finger can happen with real sterling too, from the copper in it. That washes off and does you no harm. My post on whether sterling silver earrings are hypoallergenic explains the difference.)
  • Buy from people, not from a scroll. Small handmade businesses can tell you exactly how they work and where their materials come from. A listing from an unknown seller on a big marketplace cannot.

What I do instead

I prioritise affordability, but I never compromise on quality. You will not find any of this stinky fake silver on my stall or on this website.

Everything I make is solid sterling silver, and I use recycled silver, cut, soldered and finished by hand in my Nottingham studio. Every piece over 7.78 g is hallmarked by the Sheffield Assay Office, the very same people who ran the tests for the BBC. Everything lighter than that is stamped 925, and it is legit. I pinky promise.

A full UK hallmark struck into the inside of a sterling silver bangle: Anna's AM maker's mark, 925, the Sheffield rose, the lion passant and the date letter

A hallmarked sterling silver octagonal textured bangle

And if you ever want to know more about where my silver comes from or how a piece was made, ask me. At a market, in a DM, by email. I love talking about it.

You have been warned

Don't talk to strangers, don't eat yellow snow, and don't buy jewellery that might be poisoning you. Instead, please, please, PLEEEEAASE: shop small, shop local, shop handmade.

Sterling silver heart stud earrings with the words 'If in doubt my darlings, shop small, shop local, shop handmade'

If you'd like to see what the real thing looks like, my studs start at £20, and they will still be silver in ten years.

Have a smashing day, my lovely magpies.

Anna x